Everton have 'no choice' in £451m showdown as PSR reckoning less than 24 hours away
The clock is ticking. ⏰
PSR – three little letters that every Everton supporter is sick of hearing after years of back-and-forth with the Premier League, who now locked in civil war over their financial regulations.
The two points deductions Everton suffered last season were historic in that they were the first handed out under the Premier League’s spending regulations, either under PSR or its predecessor, FFP.
Profit and Sustainability Rules are despised by many clubs because of the perception that they are in place to limit the ambitions of clubs like Everton by anchoring their spending on wages and transfers.
But Everton have lost over £500m in the last five financial years and the fact that Farhad Moshiri’s cash appears to have completely dried up is cited by many as a reason to have financial guardrails in place.
Dan Friedkin’s impending takeover will solve their cash flow issues, but the Moshiri’s reckless, scattergun approach to recruitment and retention has left a mark that won’t be scrubbed out for some time.
Everton face a third PSR hearing, although the date is not yet known and it has likely been delayed by the Man City’s Associated Party Transaction (APT) and 115 charges cases.
In the APT case, Everton gave evidence in support of Man City along with a handful of other clubs.
Everton are disenfranchises with the Premier League’s financial regulations and their relationship with the organisation is at breaking point, with the league’s spending on legal matters a particular sticking point.
One outcome of the APT case they may not have been banking was the league’s rules on soft loans becoming collateral damage in a case that was thought to be squarely about commercial deals with owner-linked entities.
Soft loans – interest-free loans from shareholders – are the subject of a meeting at Premier League HQ tomorrow, where clubs will vote on a new draft of the rules than considers soft loans a subsidy.
And that, according to one reputable finance expert, has put the Toffees in an uncomfortable position.
- READ MORE: What Everton are trying to do with Jarrad Branthwaite as Manchester United still want to sign him
Everton have ‘no choice’ but to vote against Man City in APT meeting
For all Moshiri’s faults at Everton, the British-Iranian billionaire was not frugal when the purse strings allowed.
In total, he lent the club £451m in soft loans, which he will now never get back as Dan Friedkin prepares to have his takeover ratified by the Premier League.
The vote tomorrow – which City are trying frantically to delay – will see a new set of rules brought in that apply a commercial interest for soft loans for PSR purposes.
This won’t be a problem going forward for Everton as Friedkin’s takeover will clear the decks, but Man City want the rules applied retroactively.
And now Everton, who have been City’s allies on so many areas in recent months and years, reportedly plan on voting with the Premier League on their amendments to the APT rules.
As former Man City adviser and legal expert Stefan Borson says, the Merseysiders have effectively been backed into a corner.
“Everton have no choice but to support the vote – they will need the proposed rules in respect of shareholder loans to not apply historically,” talksSPORT’s regular football finance commentator wrote on X.
How much will the Bramley Moore Dock stadium help PSR?
With Everton moving into the new stadium from the start of 2025-26, there is hope among fans that Friedkin’s first full season at the helm could be much more positive in terms of PSR.
Premier League survival is non-negotiable, but Everton’s occupancy at their new waterfront stadium will herald a new dawn in terms of PSR.
As well as matchday income, a metric in which Everton have long underperformed, commercial income will skyrocket at the new stadium.
Everton have already signed several ‘founding partner’ sponsorship deals with the likes of Castore and Aramark, while the stadium itself will be far more geared towards emptying wallets than Goodison Park.
Naming rights will also be a huge earner, with the club having appointed an agency to search for a potential partner several years ago.
The exact figure Everton’s commercial department are aiming for isn’t known, but the consensus is that £10m per year is within reach.
In terms of matchday income itself, Everton currently earn less than £1m per match at Goodison. That will likely more than double at the new stadium.
That will likely see them overtake the likes of Newcastle United and West Ham to become the biggest matchday income earners outside the so-called Big Six.
In terms of PSR, the new stadium will be truly transformative.
What's Your Reaction?
